"If At First You Don't Succeed, Lie..."
— 01/31/11

Ashley Benson, Troian Bellisario and Shay Mitchell steal the spotlight at the 2011 MTV Movie Awards held at the Gibson Amphitheatre on Sunday (June 5) in Universal City, Calif.

Want to know what those Pretty Little Liars were wearing? JJJ’s got you covered!

Shay, 24, dolled up in an Ines di Santo sparkler dress with Vahan jewels.

Troian, 25, went classy in a Christoforos Kotentos black dress and Le Vain jewelry.

Ashley, 21, who posed with Selena Gomez and MTV 10 on Top hostess Lenay Dunn on the carpet, went for the gold in a Matthew Williamson dress with Ferragamo heels and clutch. She accessorized with Amrapali earrings.

15+ pics inside…